Proactive Investors - Run By Investors For Investors

Admiral’s troubles with aren't likely to sink the price comparison site

On Thursday, the FTSE 100 insurer's founder invested US$25mln for a 17% stake in at a 15% discount compared to previous funding rounds
Admiral logo
Admiral is also expecting a full year loss connected to of between US$8mln and US$13mln

On Tuesday morning, FTSE 100 insurer Admiral Group PLC (LON:ADM) said its former chief executive and founder, Henry Engelhardt, and his wife Diane would invest US$25mln for a 17% stake in its US subsidiary, comparison site

Not to be confused (.com) with UK comparison site (LON:GOCO) or Meerkat-related, is Admiral’s attempt to bring the comparison site model to the US market.

So far, the results have been less than encouraging, with Admiral expecting to record a full year loss connected to of between US$8mln and US$13mln, while the Engelhert’s investment was made at a 15% discount to previous funding rounds for the site.

Separately, Admiral will provide Compare with up to US$10mln by way of a convertible loan.

However, despite what seems like grim reading, Admiral’s shares have moved little, up 0.3% in lunchtime trading at 2,019p, suggesting that investors view the “challenging trading conditions” as teething problems in the US rather than a more ominous sign, with some analysts highlighting the specific challenge of working through the legal framework of 50 different states.

Comparison sites still best consumer option says analyst

In addition to the muted market reaction, analyst see little to suggest that Admiral’s troubles with are a symptom of any issues with the price comparison market.

Malcolm Morgan, an analyst at City broker Peel Hunt, said that price comparison sites still represent “the best way for the consumer to re-broke their motor insurance policy”, given their internet-backed range of choice and speed.

Morgan adds that the maturity of the motor insurance market and the penetration of price comparison sites into it is not necessarily an issue.

READ: Hastings Insurance shares plunge on outlook concerns amid growing competition

He cites Hastings Insurance Group PLC (LON:HSTG) as an example of the increased use of comparison sites in policy purchases after it reported in October that live customer policies had increased 4% to 2.70mln in the nine months to September 30 as gross written premiums jumped 3% to £738.5mln, although it also noted fierce competition in the sector.

Regulatory probe just as likely to be a benefit than detriment

Worries over the state of the insurance market were highlighted recently by an announcement that the City regulator, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), would be investigating pricing practices in the home and motor insurance sectors, citing the failure of several firms to have appropriate or clear pricing, governance, and controls.

However, Morgan says the FCA investigation is just as likely than not to encourage even more use of comparison sites.

“The [Competition and Markets Authority] has consistently seen price comparison sites as extremely beneficial for both competition and protecting the consumer,” he says, adding that the review is likely to reinforce the benefits of comparison and switching rather than discouraging it.

Morgan cites the energy market as an example of this occurring when the introduction of a cap on the standard variable tariff did not “choke off” robust demand for switching services.

View full ADM profile View Profile

Admiral Group Timeline

Related Articles

September 01 2018
The group manages £7.8bn of funds: £2.8bn in the UK; £2.9bn in Sweden; and £2.1bn in the Netherlands.
Employee benefits
May 09 2019
The group provides various programmes including insurance plans, salary sacrifice schemes, discounts and rewards

© Proactive Investors 2019

Proactive Investors Limited, trading as “Proactiveinvestors United Kingdom”, is Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Registered in England with Company Registration number 05639690. Group VAT registration number 872070825 FCA Registration number 559082. You can contact us here.

Market Indices, Commodities and Regulatory News Headlines copyright © Morningstar. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of use