Proactive Investors - Run By Investors For Investors

Five reasons why JD is faring better than Footasylum

JD has a size advantage which gives it better buying power, but there are other reasons why JD is reporting record profits while Footasylum is issuing profit warnings
Fun fact…The people who founded JD also founded Footasylum

After last week’s profit warning from Footasylum PLC (LON:FOOT), investors would have been forgiven for wondering whether JD Sports Fashion PLC (LON:JD.) might have also been affected by similar industry headwinds.

Their minds were put at ease when JD responded with a record set of half-year numbers on Tuesday.

READ: JD delivers record first-half

The ‘athleisure’ retailer, which sells trendy tops, hoodies and trainers, shrugged off any suggestion of a “more challenging” retail environment – Footasylum’s words – as pre-tax profits surged by a fifth to £121.9mln.

Revenue, boosted by a couple of recent overseas acquisitions, climbed by a third to £1.8bn.

First mover advantage

Despite selling similar clothes to the same audience, analysts reckon there a few key reasons why JD has outperformed while Footasylum has floundered. First and foremost is that JD, which is now closing in on a spot on the FTSE 100, is far bigger than its rival. Footasylum has 66 stores, whereas JD has just shy of 400 in the UK alone. So, if you’ve got £100 burning a hole in your pocket and you want some new trainers, the chances are you’re more likely to find a JD store wherever you are than a Footasylum.

Overseas earnings

JD is faring better than most in its home UK market, but even if it wasn’t, it still has a swathe of stores overseas which could bail it out.

The Finish Line business in the US, which JD bought earlier this year, contributed £4.8mln towards the group’s profit in the seven weeks since its acquisition and analysts believe that could be a "game changer" going forward.

READ: Footasylum has been a nice earner for founder’s kids

By contrast, Footasylum’s relative handful of stores are all dependant on UK consumers, which retailers well know are becoming increasingly in where they shop given the income squeeze of late.

Small brands can be found elsewhere

How Footasylum has typically overcome the size difference is through selling smaller brands that millennials liked, such as Gym King and Kings Will Dream.

Those are brands which Footasylum has stocked for years and helped to grow, but they can now be found elsewhere on sites such as Asos.

When Footasylum is competing with JD to sell more established brands such as Nike and Adidas, there is only ever likely to be one winner.

Store layouts

With shoppers’ habits starting to shift towards online, bricks and mortar stores are having to work harder than ever to get people through their stores.

JD has invested heavily into the layout of its stores, with analysts commending the company for its bright, clean shops as well as the shopping experience more generally.

Footasylum hasn’t quite got it right yet. It has scaled back its plans to open new stores, a move which analysts reckon is because they realised the shops it has and the ones it has been targeting are too small.

Bad buys

One of AIM-listed Footasylum’s biggest problems has been the stock it has purchased, with City analysts commenting that the firm’s buyers have made the “odd misselection”.

That has left Footasylum with a lot of clothes and trainers that it can’t shift, forcing it to slash prices and in turn killing margins.

More importantly, argue the number crunchers, is that old, cheap stock filling the shop floor rather than the latest lines is unlikely to draw people in.

View full JD. profile View Profile

JD Sports Timeline

Related Articles

medical imaging graphic
Here we take a closer look at the imaging and diagnostics firm IQ-AI Limited (LON:IQAI)
Company is looking for more acquisitions after integration of Metro Rod
"The group's performance over the past three years demonstrates the continuing success of our strategy to access more customers and markets," said chief executive John Nichols.

© Proactive Investors 2019

Proactive Investors Limited, trading as “Proactiveinvestors United Kingdom”, is Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Registered in England with Company Registration number 05639690. Group VAT registration number 872070825 FCA Registration number 559082. You can contact us here.

Market Indices, Commodities and Regulatory News Headlines copyright © Morningstar. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of use