Proactive Investors - Run By Investors For Investors

A 'short' history of Uber’s controversies

Despite operating for less than a decade, the ride-hailing giant has already racked up an extensive list of disputes that have claimed some of its most senior executives
Uber logo
The company landed in its first legal spat less than a year after it began operating in 2010

On Wednesday, ride-hailing app giant Uber proposed the payment of US$1.9mln to settle a dispute with around 56 of its current and former workers who have claimed they were victims of sexual harassment.

The episode marks the latest tribulation in what has been a controversial history for the company since it was founded in 2009, raising questions around what can happen when a company expands at such a breakneck pace.

2010

In October, a mere year after its official founding, Uber (then known as Ubercab), received its first cease and desist letter from the San Francisco Metro Transit Authority and the Public Utilities Commission of California, claiming it was operating an unlicensed taxi service.

This was followed by a company name change to the simpler ‘Uber’, and the company remained operational despite the C&D.

While the PUC fined Uber US$20,000 and issued another C&D in 2012, an interim agreement was reached in 2013 to reverse the actions.

2012

In 2012 Uber was hit with its first wave of price surge complaints, the first following New Years Eve when prices were raised to between three and six times the normal rate, the second in November when the firm was accused of doubling its prices during Hurricane Sandy which put most of New York City’s public transport out of action.

2013

The first class action lawsuit against Uber by 350,000 of its current and former drivers in California and Massachusetts was filed in August, with drivers claiming that the company should treat them as employees rather than independent contractors, which would mandate Uber pay them minimum wage and provide benefits such as health insurance.

The case was settled out of court in 2016 for US$100mln, however this was not approved as the sum was judged to not be “fair, adequate, and reasonable”.

The company also saw a lawsuit from the family of a 6-year old girl who was killed when one of its drivers ran into a San Francisco crosswalk.

According to Uber, the driver was not covered by the company insurance at the time, because while he did have the Uber app open and was waiting to book a ride, he hadn’t accepted a fare and had no passenger in the car (meaning he wasn’t technically working for Uber at that moment).

The incident raised serious questions regarding how and when ride-hailing companies could be held liable for the actions of their drivers.

2014

Then Uber chief executive and co-founder Travis Kalanick attracted criticism when he referred to the company as “Boob-er” in an interview with GQ magazine about the apps rising popularity with women.

Following the incident, Uber’s offices in Lyon, France, also came under fire for a promotion with an app that promised to match riders with attractive female drivers.

Another bout of issues appeared in January when it was reported that top uber staff in New York City were creating accounts with rival taxi app Gett to call and cancel rides and poach the frustrated drivers for its own company. The tactic was exposed again in August when it was revealed to have been used against Lyft, another of Uber’s rivals.

In July, the company was threatened with legal action by district attorneys from San Francisco and Los Angeles if it did not change its process for vetting drivers, calling its existing model “a continuing threat to consumers and the public”. This followed several incidents of Uber drivers attacking or abusing passengers that first came to light in September 2013.

It was also revealed around the same time that Uber had a so-called “God View”, which allowed it to track user’s locations, raising privacy concerns after a manager accessed the rider profile of a reporter without her permission. The company paid a US$20mln fine as part of a deal with the New York Attorney General in 2016 to limit the use of the tool by employees.

In December, the firm saw its first high-profile ban from the Delhi region of India after a passenger said she was raped by one of its drivers, raising further questions about the efficacy of its vetting procedures.

2015

The California Labour Commission ruled that Uber drivers are employees, rather than contractors, although this was not a direct effect of the case brought in 2013 by drivers in the state.

Meanwhile, French taxi drivers accused Uber’s business model of “economic terrorism” and attacked alleged Uber drivers in Paris, causing a legal crackdown on the company.

2016

In May, Uber ended its services in Austin, Texas after it failed to overturn a stringent set of guidelines which included fingerprint-based background checks for drivers.

The company was also ordered to remove self-driving cars in California after it launched a pilot scheme without permits, followed by a litany of vehicle failures including the running of red lights.

Allegations around the company’s ‘God View’ also re-emerged after former Uber forensic investigator Ward Spangenberg sued the company alleging age discrimination and whistle-blower retaliation, adding that it was still easy for Uber staff to access passenger information using a new version of the ‘God View’ programme, now known as “Heaven View”.

2017

In February, the company was forced to pay US$20mln to settle allegations that it duped people into becoming drivers with false promises about earnings, with the Federal Trade Commission claiming most of Uber’s drivers earned far less than the rates it published online in 18 major US cities.

Meanwhile, former Uber engineer Susan Fowler published a blog post in which she accused Uber of fostering a misogynistic corporate culture, leading to an independent assessment of the company by the then US attorney general Eric Holder.

The report, published in June, was damning with its recommendations including a limit on Kalanick’s responsibilities at the company as well as the creation of an independent chairman and oversight committee. The report led to the firing of more than 20 employees from the company.

In March, it was also revealed that Uber has been using a tool, known as “Greyball”, to evade authorities in cities such as Boston, Paris, and Las Vegas and other markets where it was banned or resisted by law enforcement.

The year also saw a string of high profile resignations, beginning with senior executive Amit Singhal, who left Uber after he failed to disclose a sexual harassment allegation filed against him at his previous company, Google.

He was followed by Eric Alexander, the head of Uber’s Asia business, who was fired after it was revealed he illegally obtained private medical records of the 2014 rape victim in India, which were then shown to Michael and Kalanick.

Michael left the company shortly after, followed by Kalanick who resigned as the head of Uber following pressure from five of its largest investors, including venture capital firms Benchmark, First Round Capital, Menlo Ventures, and Lowercase Capital, and the mutual fund Fidelity Investments.

Kalanick was replaced by former Expedia chief executive Dara Khosrowshahi, while Michael was replaced by the company’s vice-president of strategic initiatives, David Richter.

A few months after the departure of most of its senior team, Uber also lost its licence to operate in London, citing the use of the “Greyball” tool and its checks on drivers.

However, an appeal by the company resulted in a 15-month probationary license being granted in June 2018 to prove it had improved its practices.

Issues around privacy also resurfaced with revelations that Apple had given the firm “unprecedented” access to features such as iPhone screen recording, as well as revelations that Uber company had tried to cover up a cyberattack that exposed the personal data of 57mln of its users.

2018

The first quarter of 2018 for Uber seemed positive, with the firm reporting a US$2.45bn profit in the period, a turn around from the previous three months when it was US$1.1bn in the red.

The company has also managed to fill the position of chief financial officer, vacant since 2015, with former Bank of America Merrill Lynch CEO Nelson Chai.

However, the company is still attracting controversy to its brand, with one of its autonomous cars involved in a fatal crash in Arizona in March.

The group is also struggling somewhat with its overseas operations, having sold its Southeast Asian ride and food delivery service to a Singapore-based rival.

The latest headache for the company, as mentioned at the start, is the new US$1.9mln sexual harassment lawsuit, which will sit atop the long pile of legal disputes the company has already racked up in its 9 years of existence.

There are signs of hope though, with the company managing to fill the position of chief financial officer, vacant since 2015, with former Bank of America Merrill Lynch CEO Nelson Chai.

2019 and beyond

With the company having seemingly turned a corner, particularly in its highest echelons, the next hurdle for Uber will be meeting its self-imposed deadline for an initial public offering (IPO) in 2019.

If the deadline isn't met, transfer restrictions on will lift on the firm's shares and could result in a mass trading, with investors having voiced concerns over the recent lack of a CFO as it will become a crucial position for not only conducting the IPO but also operating a business with Uber's size and scale.

Chai may also have his hands full convincing investors to back the company in its IPO, as despite a positive first quarter 2018's figures are still overshadowed by a more than US$4bn loss the year before.

--Adds information on 2019 IPO and new CFO recruitment--

View full UBER profile View Profile

Uber Timeline

Related Articles

Software data
November 06 2018
The product will help companies in the commodities and energy sectors by automating the processes required to ensure compliance with the FCA's regime
Jobs market
October 02 2018
A flexible jobs market, an increase in short-term contracts - all play to the strengths of the specialist in background checks
Cloudbuy's online purchasing portal
April 18 2018
"We remain convinced that we have a unique product and a great partner in NHS Shared Business Services to maximise the roll-out of PHB's and Integrated Commissioning across Health and Social Care," the company said.

© Proactive Investors 2018

Proactive Investors Limited, trading as “Proactiveinvestors United Kingdom”, is Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Registered in England with Company Registration number 05639690. Group VAT registration number 872070825 FCA Registration number 559082. You can contact us here.

Market Indices, Commodities and Regulatory News Headlines copyright © Morningstar. Data delayed 15 minutes unless otherwise indicated. Terms of use